Monday, August 11, 2008

Loaded Questions / “Are You Still Beating Your Wife?”

“Are You Still Beating Your Wife?” What a loaded question!
Many of the questions on the Washington Healthy Youth Survey and the CDC Youth Risk Behavior Survey are loaded as well. The surveys do give students the choice of answering “none,” but only after being asked in such a way that assumes the student is already engaged in the behavior in question.

During the past 30 days, on how many days did you use marijuana or hashish (grass, hash, pot)?
Have you ever seriously thought about killing yourself?
How old were you the first time you smoked a whole cigarette?

When did it become okay for the public schools* to ask students these kinds of questions without written parent consent? When did it become okay for the schools to ask students these kinds of questions at all, with or without parental consent?

*The public schools may only be the vehicle used to reach a vulnerable population. The school may be administering surveys for other agencies. Do just any agencies have access to students via our public schools? Who determines which ones and why? Who draws the line and where are they drawing it? In whose best interest is the line being drawn? Is it in your child’s best interest or the agency collecting the data?

What exception is granted to the HYS and YRBS that allows them to be administered to students in our schools without parent knowledge and consent?

Check and see if your school district is registered to administer the Washington Healthy Youth Survey. Registered Schools.

Friday, August 1, 2008

Healthy Youth Survey in the State of Washington

The Healthy Youth Survey (HYS) is administered in the State of Washington to public school students in grades 6, 8, 10 and 12. This survey is administered every other year . It is scheduled to be administered again in the fall of 2008. The survey appears to be based on the CDC’s Youth Risk Behavior Survey that is administered in many other states across the country in odd number years. The kinds of questions asked on these surveys are invasive, intrusive, offensive, inappropriate, and highly suggestive for impressionable youngsters.

A sample of the questions--
During the past 30 days, on how many days did you smoke cigarettes?
During the past 30 days, on how many days did you use chewing tobacco, snuff, or dip?
During the past 30 days, on how many days did you drink a glass, can, or bottle of alcohol (beer, wine, wine coolers, hard liquor)?
During the past 30 days, on how many days did you use marijuana or hashish (grass, hash, pot)?
During the past 30 days, on how many days did you use derbisol (wagon wheels, hope)?

These questions are asked in such a way as to assume the student already does these things. These questions suggest to students that others are doing these things and maybe they should do them as well if they aren’t already.

Supposedly notes are sent home to parents regarding this survey. Parents have to respond in writing to have their child excused from the survey. The majority of notes of this nature never make it home as they end up in the classroom trashcan. As a result, many parents are never aware this survey is being administered. Even if a parent does get this note, they will not have any idea of the content of the survey. Many parents would object to their child participating in this survey if they were aware of the survey contents.

Copies of some of the past surveys are available online. Forms A and B are for students in grades 8, 10, and 12. Form C is for students in grade 6.

You can check here to see if your local school is registered to participate in the 2008 Healthy Youth Survey. Registered Schools List.


Parents should expect notification of the survey in late September. The survey will be administered between Oct. 13 and 17.

Download the Parent and Student Information Flyer here.

Timeline for the 2008 Administration


Sep-22-08 Survey materials shipped to schools

Sep-26-08 Last day to notify parents and students per IRB requirements

Oct-13 to 17 Survey administration

Oct-24-08 Last day to return survey materials

Mar-1-09 Local reports and slides sent to ESDs, counties, and districts